that hscb advert with the ‘fishing’ bird

Posted on Thu 22.10.09 at 2:00 pm

Filed under television, videos

Tagged with advertising bird china cruel hsbc

Comments No comments yet

Spread the love
  • Twitter
  • Digg
  • Facebook
  • del.icio.us
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Live
  • Print
  • email

Does anyone else think that this advert glosses over the fact that rather than being trained in the art of catching fish for humans, these cormorants are actually effectively forced to deliver fish to their ‘owners’(?)

I don’t know what my naive self thought was happening – perhaps that the birds just liked the act of catching fish and would do it even on a full stomach? who knows – but I was clearly stupidly wrong. What happens, is the birds have a piece of string tied around their neck so that when they catch a fish, they cant fit it down their throat to eat it and the ‘fisherman’ grabs it out of their beak. Seems obvious in retrospect, and possibly even looks like it’s a clever tactic, like ‘yay – humans win over nature!’ but I cant help but feel like it’s cruel and unnecessary. Maybe before we’d learnt how to use nets and rods and whatnot, I could understand it, but these days(?) Is that the best fishing method(?) Really(?)

Bah. Boo to HSBC for glamorising tying string around cormorants necks. Boo!!

(more on ‘cormorant fishing’ here)

random other post..

This post is apparently one of a kind. So why don't you take a look at another random post?

Wed 13th Feb 2008

find 815

‘lost’ get’s even more layered

neighbours.

An eye on both the past and the future..

there are no comments yet.. you could be the first!

Add a reply..